top of page
Writer's pictureBilly

Shattering Misconceptions: LSD and MDMA as Safer Options Compared to Alcohol


A psychedelic-style image of Professor David Nutt

Decoding the Misconceptions: A Prelude


As we navigate the shifting landscape of substance use and societal norms, one issue demands our immediate attention: the perceived harm of substances like LSD and MDMA, often branded as highly dangerous compared to their legal counterparts—alcohol and tobacco.


David Nutt, a renowned professor at Imperial College and the chairman of the UK government's advisory committee on the misuse of drugs, has delved deep into this issue. Nutt's findings suggest that these widely accepted notions are not only inaccurate but potentially harmful, as alcohol and tobacco have shown to be more detrimental than many classified illegal drugs, including LSD, ecstasy, and cannabis.


Reclassifying Substance Harm: A Radical Proposition


The core of Professor Nutt's argument hinges on the need for an innovative approach towards evaluating the damage caused by both legal and illicit drugs. Based on his exhaustive research, alcohol holds the dubious honor of being the fifth most harmful substance, surpassed only by heroin, cocaine, barbiturates, and methadone. Tobacco follows closely, ranking ninth in terms of harm.

In contrast, cannabis, LSD, and ecstasy are positioned further down the list at 11, 14, and 18, respectively. This crucial finding contradicts the mainstream narrative, underscoring the necessity for a comprehensive understanding of drug harms beyond the legal-illegal dichotomy.


Political Intrusion in Drug Classification: A Grave Concern


Politics and policy-making often make uneasy bedfellows, and the case of drug classification is no exception. The decision of Jacqui Smith, the former Home Secretary, to upgrade cannabis from a Class C to a Class B substance, thereby imposing heavier penalties, exemplifies this problematic intersection.

Interestingly, Professor Nutt's advisory committee strongly advised against this reclassification. However, their expert recommendations fell on deaf ears, highlighting the often contentious relationship between scientific evidence and political decision-making.


Nutt contends that this cautious approach adopted by politicians inadvertently distorts and devalues the research findings, sowing seeds of confusion among the public regarding the actual harm caused by various substances. It's noteworthy that the initial downgrade of cannabis classification led to a marked decrease in its use, further validating Nutt's stance.


Deciphering the Risks: A Balanced View


Every substance, whether sanctioned by law or not, carries a degree of risk. For instance, Nutt acknowledges a "relatively small risk" of psychotic illness linked to cannabis use. He asserts that to prevent one episode of schizophrenia, it would be necessary to prevent 5,000 men aged 20 to 25 from ever using cannabis.

Furthermore, Nutt vocally supported the reclassification of ecstasy from a Class A to a Class B drug. Despite his committee's strong intellectual argument, the Home Secretary's veto upheld ecstasy's current status, a decision that once again underscored the divide between scientific evidence and policy-making.


Conclusion: An Urgent Call for Evidence-Based Policies


The ramifications of our current approach to drug classification extend far beyond individual users, impacting healthcare infrastructure, social equity, and overall societal wellbeing. Policies anchored in rigorous scientific evidence, rather than political expediency or moral posturing, can pave the way for a more nuanced understanding of substance use.


The fact that LSD and MDMA pose lower risks than alcohol is not a promotion of reckless consumption but a call for informed choices and harm reduction.

Stay abreast with the most recent updates in the realm of psychedelics by signing up for our weekly newsletter at www.tripsafely.com. Immerse yourself in our unique integration services here at TripSafely, and let's explore this fascinating domain together.

bottom of page